I also dont know the ins and outs, but it sounds to me if the story goes as you both tell it, that both Zenichiro and Dunccan were in the wrong.

Zenichiro should just have alkared, I can only assume he was in a bad mood and decided to take it out on someone, and Dunccan? well clearly in the wrong from what you say Zakath, but surely you are exagerrating a bit?

Orinoko

Written by my hand on the 14th of Skyelong, in the year 1074.