While I do agree with you on the speak impendiement of Arthors, I am
not so happy about your view of Shatitan and roleplay.
A role is a wide thing, made of many little things that constitute your life.
Shiaitan played eveil. He only did one thing, and that was to kill. Killing
by itself cannot be considered evil. It just is. Once daead a person will just
resurrect eventually and the cycle rolls over again.
Had he really played a role he would have worked to get as many evil people as possible under his wing and truly twist their minds to his will.
Written by my hand on the 26th of Agamnion, in the year 975.