If Dunccan were making such a claim, then I can see what prompted your post. Adding those particular details to your original post would have clarified your comments rather than leaving the door open for criticism. Suffice it to say, if you are going to post on a bulletin board meant for the masses, it is wise to ensure you provide the appropriate context.
That being said, it is still a stretch to claim that Dunccan is acting against a dictum of the creator when such actions do not fit within the context of the original 10-year-old post.
Written by my hand on the 9th of Springflower, in the year 1173.