Since you are not yet able to access the elders board where such issues should be discussed, I will address some of your concerns here. I hope it doesn't offend anyone.
The carvings, while a pinnacle skill, are hardly as powerful as you make them out to be. The paranoia is easily cured and its not like we are spreading them all over the place. I have ONE eye carving out at any given time if I am not purposefully causing some organization extra grief.
That being said, I see no problem with a tweak to the skill making them effect those off the lw list only. However, it is not my decision to make. So perhaps your post was meant to be addressed to someone far more powerful than I?
Written by my hand on the 13th of Eleuthral, in the year 1139.