Please reread my post. I claim no right to decide the fates of others.
What we do claim is the right to decide when and under what conditions we employ our abilities and how we spend our time on Avalon.
The system proposed offers more brews per year than the previous one, and should prevent arguments over interpretation of the guidelines, being considerably more black-and-white. If you have concerns about the system I outlined, feel free to bring them to my attention by a more personal method of communication.
Written by my hand on the 28th of Leaflost, in the year 1120.