I made no accusations about Phaid, other than it proves how untrustworthy he is by immediately bringing another old established character into play the minute he has a problem with phaid.
This is not good role play, regardless of what accusations Xanthe made to him and punished him for. From what I understand of the situation, Phaid was punished for his disrespect, NOT the actual rule breaking/accusations.
This is where you younger players need to udnerstand what the Gods are about. If you piss them off they will punish you, they have the skils and the divine authority. so get with the program, read HELP GODS and don't tick them off.
Written by my hand on the 19th of Ilmarael, in the year 1051.